This is Care Opinion [siteRegion]. Did you want Care Opinion [usersRegionBasedOnIP]?

"Showing no empathy"

About: University Hospital Monklands / Ear, Nose & Throat (Ward 9)

(as a relative),

Having experienced excellent care and management of a particularly difficult episode of epistaxis when my sister attended previously, unfortunately, we also witnessed the polar opposite when attending again with the same issue.  My sister was the patient but this comment is from myself the witness.  

The nurse was more annoyed at my sister having arrived "once again" and projected an attitude towards her repeatedly telling her she should try and manage this better at home and she needs to STOP attending hospital for this issue.  My sister is 69-year-old  vulnerable  and respectable lady who lives on her own but unfortunately due to a complex cardiac condition and, whilst awaiting further cardiac surgery at Golden Jubilee, is dependent on blood thinning medications.  Nurse was made aware of these details.

However, the cardiac condition such as it is was not the issue at this presentation. 

Manner was totally shocking showing no empathy, reassurance or respect.

Unfortunately, this attitude continued as the method and process of cleaning the nose was rough, taking no account of the fact this patient had a very sore face from recent management and with no explanation of what she was doing only saying that they had to get a clot out. After one or two attempts decided a head torch was needed. On retrieving the clot it was put in a tray, then opened a package and proceeded to apply cautery without explaining what was being done. My sister was wincing and gasping in the chair throughout this.  

The staff member continued to rebuke my sister for attending, and commented on her getting herself into some state. Telling her to just calm down and relax.  There was nothing reassuring or comforting in the tone reiterating to her again that she had to stop coming to hospital and give it a chance to heal properly even suggesting she should get an appointment with her cardiologist and get her medications sorted as it was as much the blood thinners causing this as anything else.  It was also implied my sister may have been picking, scratching or rubbing her nose which would knock off the scab and start the bleeding again.

My sister is intelligent and understands such things, having been an auxiliary nurse for many years.

The side needing attention last night was on the right; not having required attention on the previous visit.  The nurse then having cleared a clot, applied cautery and very roughly inserted a piece of  “seaweed” packing telling her to wait 10 minutes and left the room.  Upon return told her she could go home as she could not possibly be admitted as the bleeding wasn’t bad enough to justify that. 

Nobody had suggested or had asked for that. 

Nurse then left room to find her a chair, for us to take her through the hospital to the A & E exit. This was duly delivered to the room by a healthcare assistant and after 10 minutes or so, with no further advice from said nurse, we took her back home.

I chose not to her challenge her behaviour as it would have badly affected my sister who has also recorded HBP.

This was a 69-year-old vulnerable, respectable lady who was clearly distressed, but who was further distressed and humiliated and made to feel she was a nuisance and subsequently discharged with an instruction to STOP attending for this condition.

REALLY!!

I have 40 years NHS service and work alongside many professional colleagues.

A huge part of my duties involve dealing with patient enquiries and managing expectations therefore I am aware and comfortable within the surroundings in which we presented.

I consider my sister’s presentation that evening was poorly managed with a level of service well below standard.

To revisit the introduction I can't praise enough the standard of care and consideration received on our previous visit.

As an update to the above events - she has now been admitted to Forth Valley Royal Hospital for in-patient management of her epistaxis.

.

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Lynn McTavish, Interim Surgical Service Manager, University Hospital Monklands, NHS Lanarkshire 4 years ago
Lynn McTavish
Interim Surgical Service Manager, University Hospital Monklands,
NHS Lanarkshire
Submitted on 03/10/2019 at 13:02
Published on Care Opinion at 13:02


picture of Lynn McTavish

Dear Nose not what to do

Firstly, please accept my sincere apologies at what sounds like a most distressing experience for your sister and yourself on your recent visit to the hospital. From what you have described above, we have clearly failed to provide your sister with the level of care and compassion that we would wish to deliver to our patients.

I am assuming that as it was an issue with epistaxis that your sister was treated in our ENT Ward or Ambulatory Care area rather than in A&E, and I would be keen to share your concerns with the staff involved.

If you would be happy for me to do so, can you get in touch with me by email Lynn.mctavish2@lanarkshire.scot.nhs.uk or 01236 748748 x4135 to give me some further details regarding your visit and I can pass this on to the Senior Charge Nurse for that area.

I understand that the timing may not suit just now given your sister is currently an inpatient in Forth Valley but please feel free to get in touch at a time when it suits you both.

Please pass on my apologies to your sister.

Kind Regards

Lynn McTavish

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k