This is Care Opinion [siteRegion]. Did you want Care Opinion [usersRegionBasedOnIP]?

"Poor experience"

About: Gynaecology / Gynaecology & Early Pregnancy Inpatients (Ward 36) Gynaecology / Gynaecology Assessment Unit

(as a service user),

I attended the Gynaecology assessment unit in Ninewells following a miscarriage and I must say I was less than impressed by my experience from my arrival to my departure. I would never normally dream of complaining, but after some deep thought and having a very different experience in the gynaecology ward (ward 36), I feel it is best to highlight the issues to allow the staff in the assessment area to learn from this and hopefully improve their practice. 

On arrival, the staff we saw completely lacked enthusiasm and were unwelcoming, they were not caring or compassionate in the slightest and I felt almost as if I were just another task added to them that day, rather than a human being that required care and treatment. The care I did eventually receive I could not fault, but first impressions mean a great deal, particularly to a patient who is already incredibly anxious and upset.

The lack of professionalism that I witnessed was beyond belief. Staff members were overheard (neither did they make an attempt to speak discreetly) about how they were fed up of this place and the people in it, and how they needed a break from it. I also overheard their complaints and moans to one another about various different staff members, how they do not work together as part of a team and how it is not surprising that many people have left the department in recent months.

We heard the same staff members also complaining that they had not had the breaks that they are entitled to, and whilst I agree this is shocking, it made me feel terrible that these staff members were busy carrying out jobs that the doctors ordered for me (blood tests, scans, etc) when they had not had their break. My partner reminded me at this point that the staff members were there to care for me as that is their job, and it shouldn’t matter whether they had a break or not as we were experiencing something terrible.

Having personally worked in a toxic environment similar to what has been described in my previous employment, I hope that this team in this department get the support and guidance from management that is required to resolve the issues that they have clearly underlying, as I feel this is impacting the standard of care being provided. I would have expected in an area where people are experiencing loss and grief that the staff would be much more sympathetic, compassionate, welcoming and show enthusiasm for their jobs, it is a sensitive area and they should remind themselves that they have chosen to work there for a reason, putting working politics aside.

With regards to my treatment, I could not fault this. The doctors were very thorough and kind, my options were explained clearly and I was allowed time to discuss and decide with my partner how we should proceed. I chose to return to ward 36 for further treatment and I must say, the nursing staff in ward 36 were incredible and my experience was faultless. I was super anxious about attending after my previous experience, but I quickly felt cared for and nothing was a bother to us. 

We would like to say a massive thank you to all doctors and nursing staff on ward 36.

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Denise Marshall, Senior Charge Nurse, Obstetrics & Gynaecology - Outpatient Services, NHS Tayside 2 weeks ago
Denise Marshall
Senior Charge Nurse, Obstetrics & Gynaecology - Outpatient Services,
NHS Tayside

I manage the Gynaecology outpatient services, including the early pregnancy assessment clinic, Gynaecology clinics and the Gynaecology Assessment Unit

Submitted on 02/05/2024 at 10:09
Published on Care Opinion at 10:09


Dear elephantcz66

I am so sorry to hear of your loss.

I am also so sorry that you had the experience you describe when you attended the Gynaecology Assessment Unit. This particularly concerns me as I manage the unit and it has not been brought to my attention that anyone has these concerns or that they are not being afforded their breaks.

We currently have a blended staffing model, with staff from the inpatient area and, as such, I would really like to understand when and who were involved, so that I can direct my discussion more effectively.

I would really welcome your contact with me so that I can manage this situation, as this is certainly not the experience I want for patients attending my unit.

Please get in touch with me, I am available Monday to Friday, and can be contacted vi main switchboard, which is 01382 660111, and ask for pager 4289.

Please note that Monday 6th May is a public holiday in NHS Tayside, so I will not be working that day.

I look forward to hearing from you and am sorry again for your experience.

Denise Marshall, Senior Charge Nurse, Gynaecology and Early Pregnancy Outpatient Services

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Response from Fiona McCallum, senior charge nurse, ward 36 (gynaecology) Ninewells Hospital, NHS Tayside 2 weeks ago
Fiona McCallum
senior charge nurse, ward 36 (gynaecology) Ninewells Hospital,
NHS Tayside
Submitted on 02/05/2024 at 10:47
Published on Care Opinion at 11:22


dear elephantcz66,

Thank you for sharing this feedback of your experience of our gynaecology services at Ninewells Hospital.

Firstly I would like to offer my condolences for your pregnancy loss and I hope you are taking the time to recover now at home.

As the senior charge nurse of ward 36, I am pleased to read of your positive experience when you were with us and I will share this with the nursing and medical team. I am glad you felt cared for during your time with us in the ward. It is also reassuring to hear that you felt the medical staff explained different options and supported your choices at this sad time.

I am saddened and disappointed to hear of the lack of professionalism and compassion that you and your partner witnessed and experienced from the nursing team when you attended the gynaecology assessment unit.

Across the gynaecology service the ward team also work within the gynaecology assessment area and so this aspect of feedback will be shared with both areas.

I wish to offer my apologies for your experience as this is not the standard of care and professionalism we expect within our areas.

I know that SCN Denise Marshall has requested you contact herself in order for us to understand this in more detail. We will then work together to enable us to reflect and put changes in place.

I am also happy to be contacted and my contact details are fiona.mccallum@nhs.scot

Fiona McCallum

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k