"I felt that our religious needs were not properly catered for."

About: Forth Valley Royal Hospital / Adult mental health NHS Forth Valley Stirling Mental Health Unit / General Psychiatry

(as the patient),

I was in Psychiatric ward of the new FVHB hospital in Larbert. I used the Citizens Advice Office to place my complaint. I was not happy with the reply so complained further. Again I was not taken seriously about the needs of Muslim patients. I submitted a list of recommendations which were ignored. More involvement of muslim volunteers is an issue that could be progressed further.

I then raised the issue with the Scottish Parliament. An offer of funding for someone to do a PHD in the needs of muslim patients was communicated to me. I felt as though I had made a breakthrough.

In the meantime I made an application for medical holy spirit, based on the healing ayats of the Koran and Hadith to my Prophethood, which I was awarded, for recovery.

Also I visited the Muslim Womens resource Centre in Glasgow, which provide a list

of services for muslim women, such as, a helpline, Advocacy, Counselling, CBT, Relationship counselling, Befriending, and friendship group. I made use of the counselling and CBT service, and then publicised these services in the hospital by putting up posters of the service, and asking the hospital to do the same.

I also recommended the appointment of a part time Imam to help cater for muslim needs.

I found the health board to be non-cooperative, but the staff in the ward were reasonably attentive about my care, and catering for a female patients needs. However, I believe they fell short of the current Equality Act, by not taking any necessary steps to rectify the situation.

Also my mother is an extremely ill person, having suffered illnesses that only a faith response can help with. She suffers from a range of medical conditions and problems.

I don’t think she has ever received proper care and attention from the Health Board for many years now. For example, they failed to tell her that she was pregnant for 5 months. They did not diagnose her head pain to be serious by not checking her blood pressure, which led to a stroke, and refuse to respond to her Islamic needs in patient care.

My mother complained about the lack of the use of the black seed extract and oil as an islamic treatment but the Board took no action at all in trying to introduce islamic remedies for her.

In the future hospitals and the NHS should pay more attention to the needs of muslim patients and requests by them, as the Equality Act would expect these needs to be taken into consideration.

Thank you.

All thanks to Allah for his help

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››


Response from Arlian Mallis, Person Centred Health and Care Co-ordinator, Department of Nursing, NHS Forth Valley

Dear Muslim Person

Thanks very much for sharing your thoughts with us. There are a few things in your posting that I can respond to .

With regard to volunteer involvement, we would encourage all ethnic groups to be represented and in a recent recruitment for our Patient Public Panel we engaged with and recruited wider representation. We hope that this will inform our ongoing commitment to delivering a service which is equal and fair for all .

Within our acute hospital and community inpatient services, patients have access to an Imam, as well as a female Muslim lay adviser for the Spiritual Care Team.

A Spiritual Care Policy is in place with NHS Forth Valley. Our Chaplaincy team are available twenty four hours a day seven days a week.

Within the Spiritual Care centre, which is open to staff, patients and visitor, there is the facility for prayer or worship.

In 2009 NHS Forth Valley completed a considerable piece of work involving a range of communities to identify gaps in service delivery or areas of service improvement. You can view the Single Equality Scheme Action Plan on the Forth valley website.


Its difficult to make comments on your mum's care, however I am very pleased to hear that you thought staff cared for you appropriately.

I hope this offers you reassurance that your views are being taken seriously as we continue to improve our services for all ethnic groups.

Best wishes


  • {{helpful}} of {{total()}} people think this response is helpful