You're offline
You're back online! Refresh the page
The site has been updated! Refresh the page

"Consultant care was excellent, nursing care was..."

About: York Hospital

What I liked

The breast Surgeons and breast Oncologists are faultless - technically excellent and unusually willing to treat patients as individuals to be engaged with in decisions about their care. Unfortunately the excellence of the team is let down by the breast care nurses and admin staff who expect patients to adhere to their paternalistic expectations.

I could not care less about the standard of hospital food and how 'nice' healthcare personnel are which seem to be the focus of the standard questions allowed for on this feedback q'aire - these matters amount only to matters superfluous to whether clinical excellence is achieved. What I care about is the excellence of oncological knowledge, surgical skill and willingness to make decisions 'with' and not 'about' their patients. I want to be confident that clinical outcome is maximised and will willingly suffer a few substandard hospital meals if this is delivered. Consultant doctors deliver on these metrics. Breast care nurses seem to lag significantly.

What could be improved

The knowledge of breast care nurses and their ability to treat patients as individuals, not the homogeneous mass of emotional wrecks they seem to think we should be.

Story from


Response from York Hospital

Thank you very much for your response. Your comments have been passed to the teams concerned. We are pleased that your visit to us was in the main very positive; our aim is to provide a high standard of service which reflects the needs of patients.

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful