This is Care Opinion [siteRegion]. Did you want Care Opinion [usersRegionBasedOnIP]?

"Mental health care"

About: NHS 24

(as a service user),

This evening I called the counselling based phone service Breathing Space. I have recently lost three close relatives to suicide and addiction behaviour. Its a very difficult time in my life and I just needed someone to talk to. I usually call Samaratins, but I wanted to try something a bit different. I really regret phoning breathing space and wish I'd phoned Samaritan instead. The person who answered the call made me feel like I wasn't being listened to, talked over me when I tried to express my opinion and with the grief I'm going through I found their response of "it's just how it is" very short and lacking empathy. I feel the mental health service let my relatives down before the tragedy occurred. These relatives are extended family living outside the UK. Even though I tried to explain this, the person on the phone became very defensive and would not let me speak about what happened. I apologised, tried to explain that it had nothing to do with breathing space, nor was it personally aimed at the person I was speaking to (I've never spoken to this person before or even contacted breathing space prior to today). But their reply indicated that it was "not appropriate" for me to discuss any negative opinion of a mental health service (UK or otherwise). I was even told that my relatives deciding to take their own life was their decision, so nothing could have been done about it, and I can't blame anyone. If this person had let me speak, they would have maybe understood that as a psychology student I deeply respect and acknowledge how important mental health services are in helping people. And I also have the right to express my disappointment in such a service when my family reached out to help the now deceased relatives and did not receive the support that was desperately needed. Again, very specific circumstance not even applying within the UK, so I was shocked at how dismissive and defensive the person became. It was clear to me at that point that their best advice for me in this time was "get over it, suicide cannot be prevented, mental health services are perfect so how dare you complain" - actually I wasn't complaining. I was venting and grieving, a very natural part of the grief process, and I did not even raise my voice despite feeling angry under the circumstances. Despite all this, my anger and despair over losing my family was taken very personally and it left me feeling deflated. I ended up apologising and hanging up the phone - and then I cried on my own for a few hours. I will not be calling Breathing Space again.  

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Shona Lawrence, Clinical Governance Lead, Nursing and Care, NHS 24 6 years ago
Shona Lawrence
Clinical Governance Lead, Nursing and Care,
NHS 24
Submitted on 28/03/2018 at 15:25
Published on Care Opinion at 15:44


picture of Shona Lawrence

Dear ChooseLife

Thank you for sharing your experience of the Breathing Space service via Care Opinion. Please be assured that I have shared this with Senior Staff within Breathing Space.

I am disappointed to see your feedback and I can understand your upset regarding this. As a service, Breathing Space sets out to offer a safe place to talk about the things people struggle with and maybe are unable to talk about in their normal day to day settings. It is concerning that you feel you were not listened to and given the appropriate empathy regarding your distress. Breathing Space seeks to offer advice and signposting where appropriate and it is clear that you feel let down by the way the Advisor chose to manage your call. I am very sorry that this was your experience.

I appreciate that Breathing Space is an anonymous service. However, should you care to contact me directly to discuss this further, then I would be pleased to hear from you. You can call me on 0141 337 4582 or email at patientaffairs@nhs24.scot.nhs.uk

Some additional detail may assist us in reviewing this further to ensure that we do better in the future and for other callers to the service.

Thanks again for taking the time to share your experience. I apologise that this was not positive.


Take care

Shona

Shona Lawrence

NHS 24 Patient Affairs Manager

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Response from Shona Lawrence, Clinical Governance Lead, Nursing and Care, NHS 24 5 years ago
Shona Lawrence
Clinical Governance Lead, Nursing and Care,
NHS 24
Submitted on 27/08/2018 at 16:25
Published on Care Opinion at 16:29


picture of Shona Lawrence


Dear ChooseLife

Thanks so much for making contact with me. I appreciate it has been some time since you posted your Care Opinion story, however it was still good of you to get in touch to provide additional information on your experience of Breathing Space.

I am very sorry that you feel the service provided by Breathing Space did not meet your needs and, following our conversation today, I will ensure that your comments are shared with senior Breathing Space staff.

As explained, Breathing Space is an anonymous confidential service and, as such, calls to Breathing Space are not recorded. However, Breathing Space staff do undertake regular meetings with senior staff at which discussion takes place in relation to the caller experience. This ensures that any feedback received is managed in an open and transparent manner to ensure organisational learning.

As Breathing Spaces comes within a range of services provided by NHS 24, please be assured that we are a listening organisation and very much welcome feedback on our services.

I wish you well and appreciate you have been through a very challenging time. I am pleased to learn you are now receiving support.

With kind regards

Shona

Shona Lawrence

NHS 24 Patient Affairs Manager

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k