This is Care Opinion [siteRegion]. Did you want Care Opinion [usersRegionBasedOnIP]?

"Misdiagnoisis, medication refusals, appalling..."

About: Alpine House Surgery

When I joined the surgery I was refused medication that Ihad been on for years, based on expense.

On challenging, I was told the doctor had made a mistake on the price so I could have it. This caused me great distress.

Around a year ago I was suffering from severe itching, the doctor informed me I had scabies.

As It became worse at the weekend, I visited the walk-in centre, they informed me I had no signs of scabies, confirmed by a doctor at this surgery a week later.

However, myself and my my wife had both wasted our time treating ourselves and cleaning, again causing great stress.

I had been informed by my consultant that to start fertility treatment I needed to get my GP to refer me, I booked an appointment, the doctor didn't have a clue what I was asking for or what to do.

Finally, I went for a scan arranged by my consultant, I was called by the GP surgery and told I needed to make an appointment about the results, this caused me great stress, as clearly something was wrong, this was not something that the GP was involved in and should not have been calling me about the the results.

They had recieved a letter from my consutant a month before informing them that I was suffering from stress.

I wrote an email to complain, but their only reply was to ask me to find another medical practice.

nhs.uk logo
Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Alpine House Surgery 6 years ago
Alpine House Surgery
Submitted on 31/05/2017 at 08:40
Published on nhs.uk on 10/11/2017 at 11:17


Dear pt – we take any comments / concerns made by our patients seriously. We would be more than happy to discuss these matters in person – either with the practice manager or Doctor of your choosing. As the comments were made anonymously – we cannot make reference to your specific concerns, however are more than happy to discuss in general your concerns and outline Alpine House policies.

Firstly with regards medication – Alpine House would never refuse to prescribe medication on basis of expense. Refusal to prescribe will be dependent on Leicestershire Medical

Strategy Group [LMSG] guidance, the clinician’s experience with specialised medicine and the clinical evidence available to support the use of medicines, in particular those of low clinical value. The reasons for not prescribing hence are in patient’s best interest. If we are unable to prescribe, this will be discussed with the patient and arrangements made for alternative route undertaken. The patient will never be left without medication.

Secondly, with regards itching – this is not a uncommon scenario and there can be lots of causes for this. Scabies is one of a list of differential diagnoses that can cause chronic widespread itching, in particular if there has been a possible source and other close contacts with similar symptoms. Treatment is to usually apply cream all over for 12 hrs and poss repeat 1 wk later.

With regards referral for fertility treatment as per secondary care, this is again a common issue dealt with in primary care – so am a little puzzled as to why the Dr was uncertain of what to do in this context. Prior to referral, there is a clear pathway that needs to be undertaken including various investigations for both parties. If these investigations have not been performed, the referral will be returned directly to primary care without pt being seen with a request to undertake said investigations.

With regards investigations performed by secondary care, unfortunately it is not unusual for primary care to be simply sent results without context or without knowing who requested them. Hence it is difficult to ascertain who has responsibility/ownership and therefore, if there are any concerns, it is in patients best interest to be contacted.

Finally, with regards asking pts to leave the practice – it is practice policy to do so only if they have moved out of practice area or if there has been any aggressive/abusive behaviour at the practice – for this we operate a zero tolerance policy

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k