This is Care Opinion [siteRegion]. Did you want Care Opinion [usersRegionBasedOnIP]?

"Systemic Refusal to any post Traumatic Brain Injury care."

About: Community Mental Health Services Forth Valley Royal Hospital / Neurology NHS Lanarkshire

(as the patient),

My issues have been going on for 36 years, however, the last 3 in particular, now that I'm fully aware of the root cause and condition of my health issue, my experience has been Kafkaesque at best.

In 1984 as a teenager I sustained a Traumatic Brain Injury after falling into an uncovered streetworks excavation on a dark night, while returning home from an errand. The result was an operation to treat an Extradural Haematoma 48 hours later, having spent this time deteriorating in an A&E ward. Physically on the surface I appeared to have made a fully recovery, however, I experienced severe fatigue, headaches and sensory issues. My concentration was poor, as was my ability to retain new information. Not ideal for a teenager about to start university. After approaching my GP with my parents, I was accused of malingering and my parents were informed that all that was required was that I needed a "good shake".

Roll forward a few years after having failed university and mental health problems have came into my life in addition to the aforementioned sequelae. At every juncture with mental health services I asked if the roots of my problem lay with the TBI. At every juncture I was given a diagnosis from psychosis to GAD, OCD, or depression.

Roll forward to 2016 and I'm about to commence my third stay in as many years at a private sector psychiatric hospital after yet another breakdown and a head full of suicidal ideation. At this point the consultant psychiatrist decided to consider that there may be an organic root to my decades long mental health issues which had been, despite my best efforts, remaining unresolved. Again the TBI wasn't considered, this time it was the possibility of an ASD. One year after obtaining a GP referreral to Autism Scotland my name came up on the list for an assessment, which I had in March 2017. The Psychology team at Autism Scotland concluded that I did not meet the criteria for an ASD diagnosis, however it appeared I was suffering from issues in my pre-frontal cortex as a result of my TBI. This was confirmed in August 2017 by a private sector Clinical Psychologist with decades of experience in the field of Brain Injury.

At his suggestion my wife approached NHS Lanarkshire for assistance, only to be refused. No other mental health support was forthcoming and after yet another episode of a breakdown and suicidal ideation I spent October 2017 in a private sector Psychiatric Hospital.

I began seeing the private sector Clinical Psychologist in January 2018 and began identifying the myriad of issues that a person faces after a TBI; the headaches; the concentration; the memory problems; the challenges to my executive function; emotional dysregulation and lability; speech issues and the FATIGUE!-my nemesis; every day is a lottery as to whether I will have enough energy to carry out the basic functions that comprise my eroded daily life.  The Clinical Psychologist made it clear that additional support would be required from the NHS if I was to gain a daily existence that bore any resemblance to 'normal daily daily living'. None of this was forthcoming. I subsequently spent February 2019 again back in a private sector Psychiatric Hospital with exactly the same mental health issues and by that time we had moved home to the NHS Forth Valley area.

Since first having my long standing suspicions that my health issues were related to my TBI confirmed in 2017, my wife and I have carried out extensive research both online (and there are many peer reviewed scientific and medical papers on the subject) and with the help of the Headway Scotland charity. There is a great deal of easily accessible information out there. It begs the question; why has nobody I have encountered in the health profession with the exception of a Professor at Autism Scotland and the private sector Clinical Psychologist I have been attending been privvy to this extensive information?

In August 2019, in a moment of utter despair, I swallowed every tablet I have in the desperate hope of ending my pain and sheer trauma. I was taken to A&E and when it was established that I had not taken enough tablets to ensure the lethality I so desperately sought, I was discharged. On visiting my GP a few days later I was referred to Forth Valley mental health services. Two months later after some further calls from my GP, I received my first home visit from two Occupational Therapists. During this visit, I gave my account of the last 35 years of living with a TBI. A few days later I received a letter with what looked like a Christmas list; I would receive OT input in order to help me with my now defunct daily living skills; I would undergo a CT scan to assess my neurological health; I would receive a full Neuro-Psychological assessment; and I would be appointed a Psychiatrist.

Thus far, bearing in mind that the letter I received was in October 2019, the following commitments have been fulfilled:

1. I have received 3 visits from an OT.

2. I have had a CT scan in November 2019 however, the results have never been discussed with me other than the brief comment "your brain injury is quite obvious on the CT scan".

3. I have had one Psychiatric appointment in November 2019 where the problem with my current medication; I have been on since its prescription at the private sector Psychiatric Hospital in October 2017 was discussed owing to its lack of SMC approval. No other issues were discussed other than that I would undergo regular Psychiatric appointments by March 2020 at the very latest. This medication has allowed me a full nights sleep after more than 30 years of chronic insomnia. I have been found wanting after 30 years of a BNF full of a myriad of pschotropic medication; from the chemical cosh of Chlorpromazine in the 90's, to Tricyclics, to SSRIs of every flavour. I currently pay privately for my medication at great expense over and above the private sector psychiatric and psychological treatments I have had since 2012.

In conclusion, has my experience been;

1. Good? ...At no point has it been less than traumatic.

2. What could have been better? ... Everything, or perhaps my parents should have eschewed the Brain Operation in 1984 and allowed me to die.

3. How do I feel about my care? ...What care? At what point will anyone care? Personally, I feel my next point of contact with NHS Scotland will be to become nothing other than an entry in the book of statistics documenting yet another figure in the leading cause of death for men of my age.

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Pauline Donnelly, Person Centred Manager, Department of Nursing, NHS Forth Valley 3 years ago
Pauline Donnelly
Person Centred Manager, Department of Nursing,
NHS Forth Valley
Submitted on 21/07/2020 at 15:26
Published on Care Opinion at 15:40


picture of Pauline Donnelly

Dear Emjaykay

Firstly I would like to take this opportunity to thank you for taking the time to get in touch to tell your story, from what you have said this must have been very difficult for you.

I was wondering if I could ask you to get in touch with me, I would really like the opportunity to look further into the issues you have raised and look at what support we can offer you, to enable me to do this I will need a little more information from you. You can contact me on 01324 566523 or you can email me pauline.donnelly1@nhs.net

I look forward to hearing from you.

Kindest regards

Pauline

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Response from Jane-Marie Stobie, Lead Occupational Therapist Physical Care and Co-ordinator, Community Brain Injury Team, University Hospital Hairmyres, NHS Lanarkshire 3 years ago
Jane-Marie Stobie
Lead Occupational Therapist Physical Care and Co-ordinator, Community Brain Injury Team, University Hospital Hairmyres,
NHS Lanarkshire
Submitted on 22/07/2020 at 09:50
Published on Care Opinion at 11:24


picture of Jane-Marie Stobie

Dear Emjaykay,

Thank you for your post. I am very sorry to hear about the difficulties you have had over the years since your brain injury. I am very keen to discuss your contact with NHS Lanarkshire Community Brain Injury Team further so we can learn from your case.

I would greatly appreciate if you could contact me on 01698 377864 or email me onJane-Marie.Stobie@lanarkshire.scot.nhs.uk

I look forward to hearing from you

Kind regards

Jane-Marie Stobie

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful

Update posted by EMJAYKAY (the patient)

Three months on since my post was published. NHS Forth Valley have informed me that there is nothing further that they can do and that I am on a list for a Neuro Psychological assessment. I was informed that I was on this list by letter in October 2019.

As for the CT scan I underwent in November 2019, I have yet to have any discussion on the results. I have obtained a copy of this CT scan via a DPA request and have enough knowledge in the matter to have spotted several anomalies on my brain scan. When will these results be discussed with an appropriate NHS professional?

I have been informed that there are limited resources in specialisms in my health board area regarding my neurological issues; however there are mechanisms in place to address this shortcoming. The Managed Clinical Network is in place to address this. It begs the question, why in my case has this facility not been utilised?

Regarding the response from NHS Lanarkshire my initial telephone call was met with the sympathy and concern that it warranted. I offered to give my consent to the private sector Clinical Psychologist to share his findings with NHS Lanarkshire and not only went as far as mandating this permission but also gave consent to the private sector Psychiatrist I attended in 2018/19 to share my information.

In the previous response where they talked about learning from my case, I believed that this sentiment was genuine. It may have help me derive some meaning the suffering I have experienced over the decades and the thought that my experience could benefit others, it would have at least provided me with some positive element in my life beset with neurological dysfunctions, psychological trauma and severe mental ill health.

However, after 14 phone calls with the promise of a call back, I have yet to receive any further discussion on this matter. A window of opportunity only exists for as long as that window is open and I now consider that window firmly shut.

Words alone cannot express my intense sense of betrayal at the hands of the health profession. Notwithstanding my ongoing mental health and Brain Injury related issues this development has in no small part eroded any resilience I had left. My mental health and any hope that the healthcare system cared about my wellbeing has reached a nadir beyond that which I experienced in the worst times when I was in the throws of addiction through self-medication prior to my recovery in 2012.

I give up, on NHS Scotland and I am now giving up on the will to live.

Response from Jane-Marie Stobie, Lead Occupational Therapist Physical Care and Co-ordinator, Community Brain Injury Team, University Hospital Hairmyres, NHS Lanarkshire 3 years ago
Jane-Marie Stobie
Lead Occupational Therapist Physical Care and Co-ordinator, Community Brain Injury Team, University Hospital Hairmyres,
NHS Lanarkshire
Submitted on 21/10/2020 at 11:33
Published on Care Opinion on 22/10/2020 at 16:43


picture of Jane-Marie Stobie

Dear EmjayKay,

Thank you for taking the time to get in touch again. I am sorry you have been unable to access the support you feel you need. After we last spoke I did review your case and shared your story with the team as part of an inservice training event so we could reflect and learn from the points you raised and I would like to thank you for allowing us to do that. As you no longer live in Lanarkshire, any support you require going forward will be from NHS Forth Valley. I hope you are able to discuss the services you feel you need with them and that your health improves.

Kind regards

Jane-Marie Stobie

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Response from Pauline Donnelly, Person Centred Manager, Department of Nursing, NHS Forth Valley 3 years ago
Pauline Donnelly
Person Centred Manager, Department of Nursing,
NHS Forth Valley
Submitted on 23/10/2020 at 10:07
Published on Care Opinion at 13:06


picture of Pauline Donnelly

Dear Emjaykay

Thank you for taking the time to get back touch. Unfortunately I am unable to give you a time scale as to when you you will receive an appointment for your Neuro Psych Assessment, and understand that this must be very difficult frustrating for you.

I understand that you are still receiving weekly support from our Mental Health Team, and would encourage you to keep in touch with the team and discuss with them the concerns you have raised in your story.

I wish you well for your future.

Kind regards

Pauline

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k