This is Care Opinion [siteRegion]. Did you want Care Opinion [usersRegionBasedOnIP]?

"I expect to be shown some respect"

About: Scottish Ambulance Service / Emergency Ambulance Victoria Hospital / Accident & Emergency Victoria Hospital / Admissions Unit 1 (Emergency Medical) Victoria Hospital / Intensive Care Unit Victoria Hospital / Physiotherapy

(as a service user),

I was in hospital as I didn't feel well so I called the emergency services (I've had a problem with TIAs). The paramedics were brilliant, said lets take you into A&E, the young doctor took a look and I was taken to admissions where there were 4 beds and 3 patients.

The problem came when one auxiliary nurse came in. I asked to be called by my name, not by 'love' or 'dear' or darling' - I didn't think it would be an issue, but they just gave me this look. And then they came in to take my blood, and when I asked for the curtains to be draw they didn't see why and said they were only drawing blood. I said that should be irrelevant, my privacy is mine, even for a blood draw. That didn't go down well.

Later, a senior nurse came in and said they'd heard I had been asking a lot from the staff. Being called by my own name and having the privacy I am entitled to is not asking for a lot, its just basic respect.

They asked if I wanted dinner, said no and I want to see a doctor. Told the Dr would be busy for an unspecified amount of time. I asked if they had a paper as I hadn't brought anything to read, told no. I asked if I could pop across to WHSmiths and get one, told no. They said they would see about sending someone over. This was at 4 in the afternoon.

Shortly after a young doctor came in who was extremely lovely, said the CT scan was clear. I asked if that meant I could go home, the Dr said they would like to speak to a senior doctor first to confirm it. I asked how long that would be, told they couldn't say exactly. I said thats fair, but I'm actually feeling fine now so if 6pm comes and the doctor hasn't been, I'm seeing myself off as I don't want to sit around waiting 'til potentially the early hours of the morning, I have to think about how I'm getting home as well.

The nurse came back and asked what I wanted to eat, I respectfully declined. Offered me a drink, I said no. Offered me milk, no I don't drink milk. Juice? No, just water thanks. What do they not understand about the word no? 

It's the same thing with the blood test. What they should do, is ask if I know whats meant to happen, I can say yes I've done this before and we can move on. Instead they explain the whole thing again. They treat me as if I am feeble minded, which I am not. I am clear headed and you can tell by the way I speak, I give them respect and I want to receive the same back.

Come 6pm, I've not seen the doctor, so I asked to leave. They rounded up a young doctor who was extremely nice and asked what was wrong. I explained the situation, they suggested I waited for the consultant, but when I asked how long that would be, I got no kind of real answer. I really do appreciate that they are all very busy people, but surely there can be some kind of approximation.

When the auxiliary nurse came back, I apologised and said I had worked for 40 years in accountancy and I have always been called by my own name. And I know what it's like to be at the end of a 12 hour shift and be tired and fed up, I really admire the profession and the effort nurses put into it - but that has nothing to do with treating people with respect. To be perfectly honest, I admire these people. I have a lot of respect for all the doctors and nurses in the NHS, they really do do a good job, my grandparents worked hard to make sure that everybody has access to health, and 95% of NHS staff really are 

Even back in A&E, the nurse asked how I preferred to be called, I said by my name and they laughed and said its an important point that the staff are doing, and it worked. The treatment in admissions, I feel it's a lack of respect, I see it especially against older people. It's completely wrong, you are here to help people, that shouldn't be affected by someone's age, or background, or the colour of their skin. You should just respect them.

I've been in and out of this hospital over the past 2 years and I really do admire and respect these people. The people I admire the most are the ones I say in the ICU, they were so considerate and respectful. Except for one instance, I was suffering from several conditions at once and I was freezing cold, on the first night I asked for a blanked and was told they were all in the laundry. Once I rang my son to ask him to bring me a blanket, the staff member came back and threw a blanket at me. 

Then when the physio came in, they spent the whole time talking about their teenage daughter. You are supposed to be here to help me! Then later, someone comes in, clearly in a rush, and says they have to fit me in quick - they were supposed to be showing me how to use an inhaler, but they went through it so fast I didn't get any of it. I had to ring NHS 24 to get instructions.

Then last time I was due to be in for 10 days with serious illness, on the second day the young doctor stood in the doorway and said I could be home tonight, I was so ill at the time I just agreed, but I could barely walk. My son had to practically carry me down to the car park, where he had to pull the car round to a no loading zone. He said don't worry, I'll deal with any complaints, I'd rather break a rule than let you catch a cold.

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Alan Martin, Patient Experience Manager, Corporate Affairs and Engagement, Scottish Ambulance Service 4 years ago
Alan Martin
Patient Experience Manager, Corporate Affairs and Engagement,
Scottish Ambulance Service
Submitted on 01/05/2019 at 18:15
Published on Care Opinion at 18:15


picture of Alan Martin

Dear Cricketxm64

Thank you very much for taking the time to share your feedback on CareOpinion. I am very sorry to read that you had need to use our services and the services of our partners in the wider NHS. Being a paramedic myself I have met and talked to many people who suffer from TIA's and they seem terrifying as you are never quite sure as to how they will manifest and evolve. It sounds like a very worrying time for you. I really do hope that you are on the road to full recovery and are feeling better.

I am very grateful that you have described our staff as brilliant. It is clear that they acted with the professionalism that we would expect. In respect to the constructive feedback you have provided around the care you received from our partners I am confident that they will be in contact and consider your comments. Personal and individually focused care is very important and Patient Experience is not just about the clinical treatment, but very much about the personal treatment. As you mention, I also believe the very vast majority of our staff in the whole of NHS Scotland to a tremendous job and feedback is our best place to learn to be even better.

I wish you all the very best in the future and thanks again.

Kind Regards

Alan

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Response from Sharon Crabb, Senior Charge Nurse, Admissions Unit 1 (AU1), NHS Fife 4 years ago
Sharon Crabb
Senior Charge Nurse, Admissions Unit 1 (AU1),
NHS Fife
Submitted on 02/05/2019 at 16:52
Published on Care Opinion on 03/05/2019 at 14:06


Dear Cricketxm64

Thank you for sharing your feedback on Care Opinion.

I am disappointed to read about your experience when you were a patient in Admissions Unit One. This is not the standard of care I would expect and for that I am genuinely sorry.

I would be keen for the opportunity to discuss your experience and would be grateful if you could contact me directly on 01592 643355 ext. 29960. Unfortunately I am not on duty tomorrow, however I am on duty 07:00-19:30hrs Saturday and 08:00-16:30hrs Monday-Wednesday next week.

Please accept my apologies and I hope that you are recovering well.

Kind Regards

Sharon

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Response from Colette Ross, Charge Nurse, Intensive Care Unit, NHS Fife 4 years ago
Colette Ross
Charge Nurse, Intensive Care Unit,
NHS Fife
Submitted on 03/05/2019 at 14:34
Published on Care Opinion at 14:42


picture of Colette Ross

Dear Cricketxm64,

Thank you for sharing your experience on Care Opinion. I note the responses above from my colleagues.

I am pleased to read of your glowing appraisal of the ICU staff but must apologise that we were unable to provide a comfortable environment for you on this occasion and I am sorry for the way in which the staff member reacted to your request. This is not behaviour we would expect from our team.

.

I have discussed your care with Duncan Ford SCN ICU ext 20880, email duncanford@nhs.net, He has asked that I share his contact details with you. He would very much like to talk to you about your care.

Feedback from service users is always appreciated, it enables us to improve so thanks again for letting us know

Kind Regards,

Colette Ross

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k