Text size

Theme

Language

"5 star NHS care on Tayside"

About: General practices in Tayside Ninewells Hospital / Acute Surgical Receiving Unit Stracathro Hospital / Radiology Trauma & Orthopaedics / Trauma Admissions Unit (Ward 18) Trauma & Orthopaedics / Trauma/Orthopaedics (Ward 17)

(as a service user),

I had a bad fall on my right hip at the beginning of July and thought I'd strained a muscle. I was more or less able to cope for a fortnight but the discomfort didn't seem to be diminishing. I contacted the Kirriemuir Medical Practice just over a week later and was able to see a GP the same morning, who referred me to Stracathro Hospital for an x-ray on two days later.

Stracathro x-ray immediately contacted a GP at my Practice, who rang me to say I'd broken my hip and so she had arranged for an emergency admission to the Acute Surgical Receiving Unit at Ninewells Hospital. I was assessed by two Orthopaedic registrars who clearly explained my options but recommended surgery. From there I was temporarily transferred to Orthopaedic Ward 17 until the Consultant had had time to examine the x-rays and discuss options with his team. There seemed little doubt that a total hip replacement would be the best option, which I accepted.

I was then transferred to Orthopaedic Ward 18 in readiness for surgery. The operation went well and I was discharged two days after being admitted to ward 18.

So far, this is simply the bare bones of events following my fall. What it lacks is an account of the superlative care I received from the moment I contacted my medical practice to the point of discharge from hospital. I cannot praise highly enough the care and consideration of every member of the clinical team, including the surgeons, anaesthetists, nurses and other health care professionals. Whilst the superb skills of the Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeons and Anaesthetists determine the outcome of every orthopaedic procedure, the nursing care at ward level is extremely important. I found that every possible assistance was quickly and willingly provided. The conviviality of the nurses was not simply enjoyable but part of their professional role as care givers. No request for help went unheeded. And the physio team ensured I became mobile as soon as possible.

In sum, I cannot praise too highly the professional care provided at every level of NHS Tayside involved in my case. And last but not least, as a vegan I had no great expectation of hospital food. I couldn't have been more mistaken - the range of options and quality of food provided could scarcely have been bettered.

Finally, at discharge I was provided with the loan of a walking frame and crutches, together with a range of necessary medication. I actually don't have the words to express how extremely grateful I am to all the care staff involved, and I hope this positive feedback will reach at least some of them. 

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Michael Conroy, Manager, Imaging ( Radiology/Nuc Med/Dexa/PET/CT)Patient Access and Assurance, NHS Tayside 2 weeks ago
Michael Conroy
Manager, Imaging ( Radiology/Nuc Med/Dexa/PET/CT)Patient Access and Assurance,
NHS Tayside
Submitted on 22/07/2025 at 14:43
Published on Care Opinion at 14:43


Dear Gemani71,

Thanks for taking the time to post these positive comments about your care.

I am pleased you had such a great experience within Radiology at Stracathro and the team managed your onward referral in a timely way.

I will share your post with the Stracathro Radiology team who will be delighted with such kind words.

Regards

Mike

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Response from Caroline Stewart, Senior Charge Nurse, Orthopaedics, NHS Tayside 2 weeks ago
Caroline Stewart
Senior Charge Nurse, Orthopaedics,
NHS Tayside
Submitted on 22/07/2025 at 16:47
Published on Care Opinion at 16:47


Dear Gemini71,

Thank you for your kind words of appreciation in relation to the journey you have experienced throughout various departments within NHS Tayside.

We as a team in ward 18 are delighted to hear your time with us was a positive experience for you and wish you well on your continued road to recovery.

KR

Caroline

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful

Update posted by Gemini71 (a service user)

Thank you, Caroline 🤗

Response from Susan Anderson, Care Opinion Administrator, Patient Experience Team, NHS Tayside 2 weeks ago
Susan Anderson
Care Opinion Administrator, Patient Experience Team,
NHS Tayside
Submitted on 23/07/2025 at 12:22
Published on Care Opinion at 12:22


Dear Gemini71

Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback about your General Practice (GP). Feedback is very valuable to all areas of the NHS, and I'm sure their staff will be delighted to hear that your experience there has been positive. Unfortunately, GP practices are not part of Care Opinion at this time, as each GP Practice is an independent business. So that they can see your feedback, we would recommend that you feedback your experience directly to the practice to allow this to be passed on to the staff. The Practice Manager can give you details of how to provide this feedback to them, as per their Complaints and Feedback Policy.

Kind regards

Susan Anderson

Care Opinion Administrator

NHS Tayside

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k