Text size

Theme

Language

"Lack of care, compassion, communication and clinical skills"

About: General practices in Fife

(as a service user),

I should start by saying that I am an experienced healthcare professional.  Having recently moved to Fife I have just registered with a GP practice in Fife.  The process of registering was not altogether positive as the receptionist was less than helpful when I attended to complete my registration forms.  That is not, however, my main issue. 

I attended my first appointment with the practice to have bloods taken recently.  A member of staff (HCSW) called me through to a room and said good morning, but made no attempt to introduce themselves (#HelloMyNameIs...) or converse with me any further.  Despite being a healthcare professional I am a little nervous of needles myself and appreciate some attempt to make me feel relaxed. 

I noted that on the table next to the chair in the room was equipment for venepuncture, although this was not in a tray.  Included was an old-fashioned elasticated tourniquet of the kind that should not be used any more.  I politely pointed out that they should no longer be used and received no reply.  I then asked if disposable tourniquets were available and the staff member pointed to a role of them on top of an equipment trolley.  I asked if one could be used on me and the staff member did get one to use on me.  There was still no verbal communication with me through any of this.  The staff member appeared to lack confidence in using the disposable tourniquet, took two attempts to tie it, and tied it much more tightly than recommended (it was actually painful).  At this point I just wanted the procedure over so never said anything. 

A steret/clinell wipe was used briefly to wipe my skin (1-2 seconds) but cleaning was not for nearly long enough (30 seconds recommended), and it was not allowed to air dry (instead wiped with a cotton ball, which rather defeats the point of cleaning the skin).  Ungloved hands were then used to palpate my vein after the cleaning process (again, very poor practice), and at no point were gloves applied. 

A vacutainer system needle was used to access my vein, but was inserted far too far (almost the whole length of the needle), resulting in the needle piercing through the far side of my vein.  When the first blood bottle was applied there was no blood flow (as the needle had passed though my vein) but the member of staff did then pull back the needle until blood started to flow and completed the blood draw.  At the end pressure was applied to the area before the needle was fully withdrawn (more bad practice) and I was given a cotton ball to press on the area, which I did.  I was offered tape for the ball, which I declined and was told plasters were not available.  At this point I felt as if I was being rushed out and checked to see if there was still any active external bleeding from the site, which there was not, although a small haematoma was evident (no doubt related to piercing through the far side of the vein).  I was then told that it was my fault for not pressing for long enough. 

I left at that point but was absolutely astonished by the lack of care and compassion shown throughout the experience, as well as the appalling communication and clinical skills (and I have taught venepuncture for many years so do know what I am talking about).  I hate to think that this is the standard of care provided at this practice and feel that remedial action should be taken to address these concerns.            

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Shelley McBain, Interim Service Manager, Primary & Preventative Care, Fife Health & Social Care Partnership 4 weeks ago
Shelley McBain
Interim Service Manager, Primary & Preventative Care,
Fife Health & Social Care Partnership
Submitted on 02/06/2025 at 09:40
Published on Care Opinion at 09:40


picture of Shelley McBain

Hello newtofife

My name is Shelley McBain and I am the interim Service Manager for Primary Care. I was sorry to read your story around the standard of care provided at your GP Practice, and that you feel your appointment lacked care and compassion I would like to look into this further, with your permission please. If you could please email me at shelley.mcbain2@nhs.scot, and we can discuss further.

Many thanks, and take care

Shelley

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k