Text size

Theme

Language

"Awful A&E experience with my son"

About: Forth Valley Royal Hospital / Accident & emergency Forth Valley Royal Hospital / Paediatrics

(as a parent/guardian),

My little boy, who has only just turned three, suffered a severe fall and broke his arm. As any mother would, I rushed him straight to A&E. Given it was a weekday evening, I was surprised at how busy the department was, but I assumed we would be seen quickly given his age and that he was in significant pain and visibly distressed.

We waited for 1.5 hours before being seen by a triage nurse, who gave him paracetamol and sent us for an X-ray. Afterwards, we were sent back to the waiting room where we sat for another 4.5 hours. During this time, there was no offer of further pain relief or even a place where my son could lie down and be more comfortable. No communication whatsoever. He continued to cry in pain, and despite my best efforts to comfort him, it became increasingly difficult. It was heartbreaking to watch.

To make matters worse, several intoxicated individuals entered the department, behaving aggressively and swearing, yet they were seen before my three year old. I later found out they were occupying a bed that could have been used for my son. I find this occurence appalling.

Finally, at 2am — six and a half hours after arriving — a senior consultant exam

ined him, prescribed stronger pain relief, and arranged for a cast. At 3am we were told we'd be transferred to the children's ward to rest until morning. However, instead of being taken straight there, we were left waiting in a corridor for a porter who I later discovered had not been called. It wasn’t until I raised concerns with a nurse at 5am (2 hours later!) that anything was done. 

My son, now visibly traumatised by the entire experience, was in desperate need of rest and a place he could be made comfortable. It is deeply upsetting that even after nine hours in A&E, he still hadn't received the basic support he needed, a bed. I tried my best to hold him tightly and comfort him, whilst also supporting his arm. My only alternative was a plastic chair. No child should ever have to endure such prolonged pain and distress, especially in a hospital.

Once we were transferred to the children’s ward, the difference was immediate and remarkable. The nurses were outstanding. They not only ensured my son was comfortable and properly cared for, but they also looked after me — by then utterly exhausted and emotionally drained. At 8am, a consultant informed us that my son would need surgery. The support we received from the ward nurses was heartwarming. They took time to explain everything clearly, helped prepare us both, and truly went above and beyond.

The kindness and care we received in the children’s ward helped ease a very traumatic experience. But I remain deeply concerned about the standard of care in the A&E department. There were available side rooms and beds that could have been offered to help ease my son’s pain and help make it a lot less traumatic. The lack of action and prioritisation is not acceptable, particularly when it involves a young child in severe, visible pain.

I worry about how the delay may have affected his injury, and I know for certain it’s left emotional scars on both of us. Children deserve better than this.

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Joanne Auld, Senior Charge Nurse, Accident & Emergency, NHS Forth Valley last month
Joanne Auld
Senior Charge Nurse, Accident & Emergency,
NHS Forth Valley
Submitted on 21/05/2025 at 14:31
Published on Care Opinion at 14:31


Dear Pegasuasgw44,

I can only apologise for the negative experience you encountered in the emergency department from admission to discharge to the children's ward.

I would be very grateful if you could send me you Sons details via email/or phone call and I will investigate the incident thoroughly and one of the SCN's will call back.

kind regards

Joanne Auld

Senior Charge Nurse

Emergency Department

01324 566116

joanne.auld@nhs.scot

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Response from Karen Macfarlane, Department Manager/Senior Nurse, Women,Children & Sexual Health, NHS Forth Valley last month
Karen Macfarlane
Department Manager/Senior Nurse, Women,Children & Sexual Health,
NHS Forth Valley
Submitted on 23/05/2025 at 13:18
Published on Care Opinion at 13:18


Dear Pegasuasgw44,

Thank you for taking the time to share your experience with us about your time in our Children's Ward.

It is lovely to hear you and your son felt supported and cared for in our ward during what sounds like a traumatic time.

I will share your lovely feedback with the staff on the ward.

I am sorry to read you did not have a good experience in the Emergency Department, I would encourage you to contact them as requested for further support.

I hope your son is continuing to recover well.

Kind regards

Karen Macfarlane

Department Manager for Paediatrics & Neonates, NHS Forth Valley.

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k