Text size

Theme

Language

"Care not personalised, neuro-affirmative, or trauma-informed"

About: Royal Hospital for Children and Young People (Edinburgh) / Physiotherapy

(as a parent/guardian),

Immersive Reader

I was in hospital for 12 days with my teenage autistic daughter, who underwent spinal surgery. 

Post op she received physio. My daughter is neurodivergent. She also has demand avoidance (or PDA Pathological demand avoidance) , as well as  a history of  trauma from a previous hospital admission ( she stopped speaking for several months after her last hospital stay two years ago). She therefore needed some alterations to her care, and specifically to how she was approached.  I have several grievances re the physio service my daughter received and I am mentioning them here, so that lessons can hopefully be learnt:

1. I mentioned my daughter's  trauma history and her PDA to the physio,  and requested that they negotiate with her, rather than using too firm an approach . They did try to change their approach during the session after I mentioned this but then during a follow up session insisted that my daughter stayed seated  in her chair whilst she was crying and clearly didn’t want to do this (I wasn’t there, my husband was though and daughter told me afterwards how horrible this was for her) . Following this negative and traumatising experience, she refused to do any sitting during the remainder of her hospital stay after physio discharged her and is now , nearly 1 month post op, also still refusing to sit at home .

This could and should have been handled better and I strongly feel  that my daughter’s experience is negatively impacting her recovery . If I could make a suggestion, it would be really helpful if physio had asked What Matters To You, and they should do this routinely with any neurodivergent youngsters as they might require different approach /timescale for discharge . This means they could stand a better chance of getting it right for each young person . 

2. I do appreciate that the  physio service is very busy but I feel that my daughter was discharged too early . The moment she could walk stairs, we were handed a discharge leaflet. However we were still in hospital for another 6 days or so afterwards and we would have appreciated if a physio had checked in on my daughter's progress, especially as she is neurodivergent and there were additional barriers for her . My daughter did not get up and mobilise enough during  the remainder of her hospital stay . She felt really anxious to walk in the hospital corridor  due to her social anxiety and the nurses looking at her. However, if physio had provided further sessions we might have got her into some sort of routine. 

3. After discharge, i  made a point of speaking to the physio and one of their colleagues in the corridor. (I didn’t know at this point that we would be in hospital for so long) . I asked if they could refer my daughter for community physio follow up for when she gets home. I explained our family situation (my husband has respiratory failure and therefore cannot walk with daughter) and my concerns that daughter, due to her PDA (pathological demand avoidance) would not mobilise for us but she would mobilise for other people., so therefore it would be good for someone to follow up . The physio said sorry , but this service was not available. However the leaflet they gave to me (for mobile patients) clearly stated that if you felt that further physio would be beneficial, you could ask to be referred . This was confusing . 

Admittedly I was very sleep deprived and crying at the time so I might not have put my point across very clearly . However, I tried to make my point several times but despite this they physio and their colleague kept insisting that the family needed a social work referral. I did not feel listened to but talked at , and this was not helping and made me feel more upset . I also found it very undignified to speak in the corridor whilst I was crying , it would have helped if physio had  come back later and / or spoken to me somewhere quiet . 

In summary , I feel overall very disappointed about the service that we received  from physio during our hospital stay . I felt it was neither person centred , neuro-affirmative nor trauma informed,  and that instead a “one size fits all” approach was used.  My hope is that staff can reflect on our experience and use more person centred, compassionate care . I have asked our consultant to refer our daughter for community physio as she is not making progress as she should . 

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Kathryn Sharp, Head of Service, Physiotherapy, Royal Hospital for Children and Young People (Edinburgh) last month
Kathryn Sharp
Head of Service, Physiotherapy,
Royal Hospital for Children and Young People (Edinburgh)
Submitted on 02/05/2025 at 13:54
Published on Care Opinion at 14:32


Immersive Reader

Dear Rucki

I would like to thank you for sharing your story regarding the Physiotherapy care your daughter received following her spinal surgery. I really appreciate the detail you have gone into with your feedback as it helps us to identify where we can learn and improve our service.

I’m sorry to hear about the issues with how your daughter was asked to remain up sitting in her chair when she clearly didn’t want to. Our aim it to ensure a child or young person’s views and needs guide the care plan. Thank you for your suggestion of ensuring we always ask What Matters To You to make sure this is clear.

I appreciate your concerns regarding your daughter being discharged from the physiotherapy service too early, and I would like to apologise for the mixed information given regarding community physiotherapy. I’m also really sorry that when you asked about this, you were not made to feel listened to. I understand this would be upsetting, especially after all you had been through.

I will be sure to discuss the issues you have raised with the Clinical Team. We are always looking for ways to improve our service, so I was wondering if you would feel comfortable to meet with us or arrange a telephone call so we can learn more from your experience. If you would feel up for this, please can I ask you to provide your contact details to the Patient Experience Team by sending an email to LOTH.Feedback@nhs.scot, making reference to this Care Opinion story. Please be assured that if you prefer not to follow up with this, we will still review your concerns and suggestions with the team.

Thank you

Kath Sharp

Head of Service - Physiotherapy Children and Young People

  • 0 people think this response is helpful