Text size

Theme

Language

"Not Person Centred Care"

About: Raigmore Hospital / Accident & Emergency Raigmore Hospital / General Medicine

(as a service user),

We were recently informed by the consultant my dad may have to go to Aberdeen for a brain bleed operation and they would monitor him in High Dependency during the night. An hour later without any discussion or rationale we were told he was going to Ward 5C and that we could not go with him. No-one was able to advise why the destination had changed, which was very worrying and confusing for us all. 

We tried to explain that we were worried about Dad and he was confused and wanted to follow him through to the ward to see him settled and answer any questions from the ward staff. We were advised by a nurse/HCSWin A&E that we were to go home and as a rule relatives were not allowed to go with their family members or to the ward. We didn't understand this strange rule or the rationale for it.  We were very worried and concerned that we may not even see him again. 

Surely there is not a blanket rule for all?  Why did this nurse make a decision about Ward 5C not allowing visitors when they work in A&E? We asked to speak to someone about not be allowed to go with Dad, and the Nurse responded no-one was available to discuss this further as everyone was busy and this was the rule!  Not a very empathetic or compassionate response!

He went to get a chest x-ray and then onto the ward. When I got to my accommodation I phoned  ward 5c as I was terribly worried about Dad and spoke directly to the doctor, who was delighted to hear from me as my dad was very confused and they needed to clarify information including his next of kin detail, past medical history and how he functions day to day. They were concerned his confusion was due to his brain injury getting worse. Dad was really upset too as he had fallen asleep on the way to Ward 5c and was disorientated and distressed when he woke up. Having family present when he woke would have been more reassuring for him.

I don't understand why I was informed there was blanket rule for all patients that family are not allowed to accompany their relative's transfer to a ward. I do not feel this is person centred care and actually added additional stress and upset to my father and his family. This also caused a delay in sharing important information with the medical team on Ward 5c.

Why is this a rule? How does this rule benefit, patients and staff? 

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Sylvia Fraser, Clinical Governance Facilitator & NHS Highland Operational Lead for Care Opinion, Clinical Governance, NHS Highland 2 months ago
Sylvia Fraser
Clinical Governance Facilitator & NHS Highland Operational Lead for Care Opinion, Clinical Governance,
NHS Highland

I am part of the overall team who manages complaints for NHS Highland and are known as the Feedback Team. We offer patients, relatives, MPs/MSPs, staff and anyone who requires assistance is registering a concern or formal complaint.

Submitted on 08/04/2025 at 11:44
Published on Care Opinion at 11:44


picture of Sylvia Fraser

Dear Bleather

Thank you for contacting NHS Highland though Care Opinion to note your experience following your attendance at NHS Highland Emergency Department with your father.

Please accept our sincere apology for the delay in acknowledging, and responding to your post.

I’m very sorry to hear about your negative experience.

We try to support patients and their families during the admission process and understand after a brain injury it can be disorienting and at times a distressing experience.

If you would be comfortable doing so, I would encourage you to contact us through NHS Highland Feedback Team. We would happily look at your concerns and your father's admission and reply in more detail to you personally.

You can contact us at nhshighland.feedback@nhs.scot, or by calling us on 01463 705997.

With kind regards

Dr Duncan Scott, Consultant Physician/Clinical Director, Medical Division

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k