This is Care Opinion [siteRegion]. Did you want Care Opinion [usersRegionBasedOnIP]?

"Uncaring, dismissive manner of the doctor"

About: Queen Margaret Hospital / Urology

(as a service user),

I am an older gentleman on the wrong side of 70 with no medical training.

In November 2009 I was admitted, by ambulance, to Queen Margaret Hospital in Dunfermline where I passed a kidney stone. I attended a follow-up appointment and the doctor advised that I required, what was explained to me as, a straightforward 10min. operation to remove a further stone.

The operation was performed in May 2010 and in the course of the procedure, my enlarged prostate gland was perforated. I bled for three weeks.

Afterwards I attended six monthly monitoring appointments for scans and flow tests and took Finasteride as prescribed. I was advised to have another operation to remove remaining stones although I was not in any pain.

I had this operation in July 2015 which again was not successful and I had to have a urinary catheter fitted for 3 weeks. Up until this point, I felt that the doctors had my best interests at heart and spent time explaining what was required, why it was required and I was unlucky in the resulting failures of both procedures.

Naturally, I am extremely reluctant to go through this procedure again as it took me many months to fully recover from each of the previous ones and they, I understand, were unsuccessful. I continued to attend appointments for flow tests and scans.

Earlier this month I attended my appointment at Queen Margaret Hospital Dunfermline and left feeling extremely unhappy, undervalued and distressed by the doctor's whole approach to my care and my concerns. They were most unhelpful and abrupt and stated that as I am very reluctant to allow them to operate for a third time, with no guarantees, that I would be wasting their time and so did not wish to offer me any further appointments.

I was told I was on the maximum amount of medication they could offer and no attempt was made to investigate or explain if there were any other options available to me. I was offered no further assistance in managing this condition and whilst I understand that it could become acute in the future I feel that a little more empathy and understanding of my fears and worries, combined with taking my whole medical history into consideration would have helped me greatly.

I feel that even yearly appointments would be reassuring. I do not like to feel that I am a waste of anybody’s time and would like this doctor to be aware of how they left me feeling.

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Arlene Brown, Head of Nursing, Planned care, Planned Care, NHS Fife 6 years ago
Arlene Brown
Head of Nursing, Planned care, Planned Care,
NHS Fife
Submitted on 21/08/2017 at 15:57
Published on Care Opinion at 16:41


picture of Arlene Brown

Dear JCP,

I am sorry to read your disappointment in the standard of care you have received under our Urology Service.

I would be very pleased to discuss this further with you and I can be contacted on

01383 623623 ext 22937.

Regards Arlene

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful

Update posted by JCP (a service user)

Hi Arlene,

Thank you for listening to my problem and for agreeing to arrange to send out a follow-up appointment. It has not arrived yet - can you advise please as I worry that it may not be forthcoming.

Regards,

JCP

Response from Arlene Brown, Head of Nursing, Planned care, Planned Care, NHS Fife 6 years ago
Arlene Brown
Head of Nursing, Planned care, Planned Care,
NHS Fife
Submitted on 30/08/2017 at 22:01
Published on Care Opinion on 31/08/2017 at 10:08


picture of Arlene Brown

Dear JCP,

Thank you for your updated post and for speaking with me on the telephone today where we discussed your follow up arrangements.

Thank you also, for explaining to me in more detail your disappointment in the standard of care when you attended for your recent out patient appointment and the impact this has had on you. On behalf of the service I would like to reiterate my apologies. As discussed this feedback is very important to us and will be used appropriately with the staff involved to ensure there is reflection and learning from this.

Thank you again and as agreed I will check in 3 months time to ensure your OPD appointment has been sent out to you to attend the VHK.

Regards Arlene

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful

Update posted by JCP (a service user)

Dear Arlene,

Thank you for your assistance in resolving my problem and thank you to Care Opinion for the ability to open dialogue in such circumstances.

Regards,

JCP

Response from Arlene Brown, Head of Nursing, Planned care, Planned Care, NHS Fife 6 years ago
Arlene Brown
Head of Nursing, Planned care, Planned Care,
NHS Fife
Submitted on 01/09/2017 at 12:51
Published on Care Opinion at 13:35


picture of Arlene Brown

Dear JCP

I was very happy to support you and thank you for this feedback.

Regards Arlene

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful

Update posted by JCP (a service user)

Hi Arlene,

Thank you for helping to arrange the follow-up OPD appointment which did not automatically appear. The appointment was a much better experience, providing information, attention and assistance and making me feel that someone actually cared about my issues and my options.

Regards

JCP

Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k