This is Care Opinion [siteRegion]. Did you want Care Opinion [usersRegionBasedOnIP]?

"Not treating patients in a dignified and respectful way"

About: University Hospital Monklands / General Surgery (Wards 4 & 7)

(as a relative),

I am very upset to post about a very alarming experience in wd 4 Monklands hospital.

My husband was admitted recently, the medical care he has received has been fantastic and we are very happy with this. The trained nursing staff have also been professional and supportive.

I am very upset about the way some of the nursing assistants spoke to patients in the ward. I cant believe it is acceptable to shout rudely to patients. The patient in the bed next to my husband was shouted at and what felt like ganged up on by these staff. Myself and my family were horrified. My daughter was in tears leaving the hospital as she felt uncomfortable for the patient and concerned about her dad being in such an environment. 

My husbands operation had to be postponed, we totally understand this and the reasons for this were well explained. He is currently on pass, this caused some confusion as we were given many explanations as to what this means. When he was having his evening meal whilst waiting his discharge prescription (his first meal of the day) a member of staff came into the room asking him to move while she made his bed as he was being discharged. I stated he was on pass and was going to ask what does this mean, can he come back if there is a problem as by this time he had been given various explanations of what that means when she very rudely said we cant keep a bed for a week for you I mean he's seen what this place is like.   I said no he hasn't as he's just in this one room, so he cant see the ward and also there is no need to speak to him this way. She then told me I had upset her and left.

Soon after we heard it being discussed how rude I was and how upset this member of staff was. This is the same staff member that shouted at the patient the day before and in my opinion was very rude to my husband.

I think it should be taken into account than when people aren't used to being in a hospital environment things should be explained clearly, this is after all a stressful event. I think patients should be spoken to in a dignified and respectful way. I also think care should be taken to protect peoples dignity and privacy.

There are many other similar instances of rudeness I could report but as this a public forum I wont go into specifics.

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Lynn McTavish, Interim Surgical Service Manager, University Hospital Monklands, NHS Lanarkshire 7 years ago
Lynn McTavish
Interim Surgical Service Manager, University Hospital Monklands,
NHS Lanarkshire
Submitted on 13/03/2017 at 16:25
Published on Care Opinion at 16:37


picture of Lynn McTavish

Dear connie L

I was concerned to read your comments regarding the interaction your husband and your family have had with members of the nursing support team in Ward 4. Clearly, this is not the way we would wish our patients and their families to feel when under our care and I am sorry that this has been the case. I am aware that this must be a very stressful and worrying time for you and your husband and would be happy to look into this furter for you, if you would like to contact me on 01236 748748 x4135. In the meantime, I will pass your comments on to the Senior Charge Nurse in Ward 4 to discuss with her staff. I am sure she who would also be happy to speak to you regarding this if you would find it helpful.

Kind Regards

Lynn McTavish

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Response from Ruth Thompson, Chief of Nursing Services, Monklands Hospital, NHS Lanarkshire 7 years ago
Ruth Thompson
Chief of Nursing Services, Monklands Hospital,
NHS Lanarkshire
Submitted on 14/03/2017 at 17:04
Published on Care Opinion at 17:12


picture of Ruth Thompson

Dear connie L

Thank you for taking the time to post you and your husband's experiences in ward 4, Monklands Hospital, I am so sorry that it was not a positive experience for your family.

Thank you for your positive comments regarding the professionalism of the trained staff, however as the Chief Nurse for the hospital it is my expectation that all staff are professional and treat patients with dignity, respect and compassion.

Having a loved one in hospital is a very stressful time and we have undoubtedly added to your anxiety, please accept my apologies for this. Staff should understand the need for clear communication to reduce anxiety and worry for patients and their families; we are undertaking many pieces of work to ensure patients and their families are equal partners in the decisions regarding their care. I will discuss your posting with both the Senior Nurse and Senior Charge Nurse of ward 4 to ensure your feedback is used to improve services.

You indicate you have numerous examples which you could share with me, I would be very keen to discuss these issues with you. I'd be very grateful if you would contact Melanie MacLean, Patient Affairs Manager on 01236 713065 who can arrange a suitable time to meet with you.

You intimate your husband's surgery has been postponed, I do hope he now has a date for this, thank you for your understanding of why this delay has arisen.

Kindest regards

Ruth

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful
Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k